A federal judge has blocked the Trump administration from enforcing civil penalties of up to $1.8 million against migrants who remain in the United States after receiving final deportation orders, delivering a significant legal setback to one of the administration’s most aggressive immigration-enforcement tools. U.S. District Judge George O’Toole Jr. in Boston ruled that the government’s fine system was imposed unlawfully and that continued collection could drive affected migrants into insolvency.
The decision does not erase final removal orders or grant immigration status to people who received the penalties. It instead targets the way the Department of Homeland Security and immigration authorities structured and enforced the fines, leaving the administration free to continue pursuing deportations through other lawful mechanisms while the case proceeds.
Trump Migrant Fines Face a Nationwide Legal Block
The disputed penalties were based on a provision of federal immigration law that authorizes daily civil fines against people who willfully fail to depart after a final removal order. Under the Trump administration’s second-term policy, the government assessed penalties of $998 per day and sometimes applied them retroactively for as long as five years, allowing an individual notice to approach $1.8 million.
The scale of the program made the ruling nationally significant. As of July, DHS had issued more than 103,000 fines totaling roughly $84 billion, according to figures cited in the litigation, showing that the policy was not a marginal enforcement experiment but a major component of the administration’s broader attempt to pressure people with final removal orders to leave the country.
The administration’s strategy fits within a wider second-term push to expand interior immigration enforcement, detention and removals. American News Brief has previously covered how courts have imposed limits on parts of the Trump immigration detention policy, underscoring that many of the administration’s most consequential enforcement measures are now being tested in federal court.
Judge Says the Government Skipped Required Procedures
O’Toole found that the government likely violated the Administrative Procedure Act and related statutory requirements when it changed how the civil penalties were imposed and challenged. The court concluded that the administration’s standardized penalty notices did not adequately set out individualized allegations showing why a particular person’s failure to depart was willful.
The judge also focused on procedural changes made in 2025 that streamlined the fine process. The administration removed a 30-day notice period and restricted opportunities to contest penalties, but the court found that those changes should have gone through the notice-and-comment process required for substantive federal rulemaking.
The ruling was issued in Maria L. v. Mullin, a class-action challenge brought by two immigrants and the Immigrant Legal Resource Center against DHS, Immigration and Customs Enforcement and other federal defendants. The plaintiffs argued that the government had imposed massive fines without adequately considering individual circumstances or providing a meaningful way to challenge whether the statutory requirements had been met.
What the Ruling Does and Does Not Change
The court’s order blocks enforcement of the challenged fine regime while the litigation continues, but it does not cancel underlying deportation orders. Migrants subject to final removal orders may still face detention, removal and other immigration consequences under federal law, and the government can continue to pursue enforcement through procedures that satisfy statutory and constitutional requirements.
That distinction matters because the administration can still argue that Congress expressly authorized civil penalties for failure to depart. The immediate legal problem identified by the court was not simply that immigration fines exist, but that the executive branch used procedures the judge found incompatible with federal administrative law and with the statutory framework governing the penalties.
The government could appeal the ruling, and the litigation may ultimately produce a narrower or broader interpretation of the administration’s authority. Until then, the injunction creates practical uncertainty over how DHS can collect existing fines and whether the agency will attempt to revive the penalty system through a new rulemaking process.
Why the $84 Billion Figure Matters
The roughly $84 billion in assessed penalties illustrates the extraordinary leverage the policy was designed to create. For people with limited incomes, even a fraction of a million-dollar fine can be effectively uncollectible, which raises questions about whether the penalties function primarily as a realistic debt-collection mechanism or as pressure to induce voluntary departure.
Supporters of tougher enforcement argue that final removal orders must carry consequences if the immigration system is to retain credibility. A government that obtains a lawful removal order but lacks practical tools to ensure compliance can create incentives for people to remain indefinitely, especially when immigration courts and enforcement agencies are already burdened by large caseloads.
Critics counter that the government cannot bypass procedural protections simply because the policy goal is aggressive enforcement. Their argument is that due process and administrative-law requirements are especially important when the government is imposing penalties large enough to threaten homes, wages, vehicles and basic financial stability.
Another Court Test for Trump Immigration Policy
The decision adds to a growing list of cases testing the boundaries of President Donald Trump’s immigration agenda. Federal courts have recently confronted disputes over detention without bond hearings, third-country deportations, visa restrictions and other executive-branch efforts to accelerate removals or reduce procedural obstacles.

Those cases do not all point in the same ideological direction, and several Trump policies have survived judicial review while others have been blocked. The common issue is how far the executive branch can go under existing immigration statutes without new congressional authorization or fuller administrative procedures.
The migrant-fines case could now become a significant precedent for that broader question. If the administration wants to preserve the policy, it may have to defend the underlying statutory authority on appeal, rewrite its procedures or both, while the plaintiffs seek to turn the current injunction into a lasting nationwide restriction.
